The Conviction Pyramid
This post is not yet published. Please don't share this link.
If you know something that others don’t, one natural question that might come to mind is: how do I actually profit from this? Beliefs are great, but most of them disappear when you have to risk capital.
Here’s my two cents. How do I capture at least two cents of value?
This is called the The Conviction Pyramid and it’s my framework for monetizing beliefs. As you move up the pyramid, the “noise” fades away, and skin in the game increases.
Level 1: The Noise (Zero Skin in the Game)
Most of what you see on the internet lives here. It requires the least amount of actual conviction because you aren’t betting on the information being true; you are betting on your ability to sell the information.
- The Guru: Create a marketing personality around your belief. If it’s a non-obvious fact, you can generate a following based on the novelty of the information alone.
- The Course Seller: Sell informational content with a money-back guarantee. It’s a step up from just tweeting, but ultimately, it’s just noise. If you were truly confident in the information, you wouldn’t be selling it for $99.
Level 2: The Arena (Skin in the Game)
This is where you actually start putting your money where your mouth is. You are no longer monetizing the audience; you are monetizing the outcome.
- The Prediction Market: Place bets in a market like Kalshi or Polymarket. You are directly wagering capital on your belief coming true.
- The Operator: Build a business based on this information. You are investing time, sweat equity, and capital to build infrastructure around your conviction.
Level 3: The Pinnacle (The Convexity of Conviction)
At the very top of the pyramid, we strip away the noise entirely. This is the realm of pure financial mechanics, where your conviction is translated directly into asymmetric risk profiles. There are two ways to play this, and they represent opposite sides of the same coin.
The Hedge Fund (Uncapped Upside, Capped Downside): You trade in markets based on this information. When you buy an asset or start a fund based on a deep conviction, your downside is strictly capped: the worst that can happen is your position goes to zero. But your upside? Infinite. You are hunting for asymmetric, exponential returns based on being right when the rest of the market is wrong.
The Insurer (Capped Upside, Uncapped Downside): You write insurance policies based on this information. This is arguably the truest, most terrifying form of quiet confidence. When you underwrite insurance (or issue credit default swaps), your upside is strictly capped: you only ever collect the premium. But your downside? Effectively uncapped. A catastrophic miscalculation can wipe you out entirely.
To sell a course is to say, “I think I’m right.”
To start a hedge fund is to say, “I am so sure I’m right, I will risk my capital for infinite reward.”
To write an insurance policy is to say, “I am so universally certain this won’t happen, I am willing to risk total destruction just to collect a few pennies in front of the steamroller.”
Everything else is just noise.